Public Citizen, Oct. 20, 2011
Use of Anti-Clotting Drug Should Not Be Expanded to Prevent Strokes, Public Citizen Tells FDA
Drug Proposed as Long-Term Therapy for Stroke Prevention Has Questionable Safety and Effectiveness, Clinical Trial Raises Ethical Concerns
WASHINGTON, D.C. – A drug that is used and approved to prevent blood clots following orthopedic surgery should not be additionally approved to prevent strokes and systemic embolism in patients with a common heart rhythm disorder because its safety and effectiveness are uncertain, and two proven drugs already exist to treat this condition, Public Citizen said in a letter sent today to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
The drug, rivaroxaban, also known as Xarelto, may cause a rebound occurrence of strokes when the medication is discontinued, and the uncertainty surrounding the clinical trial testing the drug prompted three FDA reviewers to explicitly recommend against approving the drug for this additional use.
Problems with this trial centered on the inadequate use of warfarin, the standard treatment to prevent such strokes, in the control population, thereby falsely making rivaroxaban appear superior. Other concerns included the companys unjustified decision to test a single, once-daily dose of rivaroxaban, despite evidence from previous studies that a twice-daily regimen was safer. In addition, the failure to provide adequate warfarin therapy during and after the trial exposed patients to life-threatening risks, raising ethical concerns about the conduct of the trial, Public Citizen said.
“With so much uncertainty as to whether rivaroxaban is truly as safe and effective as existing therapy to prevent such strokes, and with two drugs already available to treat this condition, the FDA must not rush to approve rivaroxaban for such a broad use, said Dr. Sammy Almashat, a researcher with Public Citizens Health Research Group and co-author of the letter.
The FDA approved rivaroxaban in July 2011 for short-term use in the prevention of blood clots in patients who undergo surgery of the hip or knee. Now, the company is asking the FDA to approve the drug to treat a different condition: strokes in patients with a relatively common heart disorder called atrial fibrillation. This new proposed use would expand the drugs market enormously, exposing potentially millions of patients to a medication that has yet to be proven as safe and effective as warfarin, a decades-old drug and the main-stay treatment for this condition.
An FDA advisory committee on Sept. 8 recommended that rivaroxaban be approved for the additional use despite FDA reviewers explicit recommendations that it not be because of the flawed clinical trial. Even some advisory committee members voting in favor of approval implicitly acknowledged that rivaroxaban is not as safe and effective as existing therapies. They recommended that the drug be restricted for use as a third-line treatment to be used only when the other two proven therapies fail.
The FDA should follow the recommendations of its expert reviewers and reject the new request to approve rivaroxaban to prevent strokes until the drugs manufacturers conduct another, better-performed clinical trial, Public Citizen said. Public Citizen also called on the agency to investigate the design and conduct of the clinical trial and the manufacturers failure to provide certain patients with the appropriate standard of care.
FDA panel, staff at odds over drug
September 9, 2011 - Outside advisers to the Food and Drug Administration have voted to recommend that the agency approve a new anticlotting drug developed by Johnson & Johnson and partner Bayer Healthcare.
Thats despite a negative review by FDA staff of the drug, Xarelto, released two days ago.
Nine panel members voted to recommend approval, two voted against, and one person abstained. The FDA is expected to make a final decision by early November.
The recommendation, after a daylong hearing, is to allow sales of the drug for preventing strokes in patients with a common irregular heartbeat known as atrial fibrillation.
Xarelto, known chemically as rivaroxaban, has been seen as a future blockbuster drug.
The FDA had approved the drug in July for patients getting knee and hip replacements, a much smaller group that has a heightened risk of dangerous blood clots.
On Tuesday, a 388-page report by FDA staff reviewers recommended against approving Xarelto for patients with atrial fibrillation, in which the hearts upper chambers quiver ineffectively - temporarily or for years. That reduces blood flow through the heart, raising the risk of dangerous blood clots forming and triggering a stroke.
The reviewers wrote that results of a late-stage study of more than 14,000 patients dont make clear how safe Xarelto is, or whether its as effective as the widely used drug warfarin. They stated that an additional study of Xarelto is needed, citing questions about potential stroke and bleeding risks among other issues. During yesterdays meeting before the FDAs cardiovascular and renal drugs advisory panel, J&J officials argued their data show Xarelto is safe and effective.